Local police, the FBI and Michigan police already searched the same lake on January 23 for Dr.
Teleka Patrick of Kalamazoo, Michigan who disappeared on December 6, but didn't find any evidence related to her disappearance.
The 133-year-old church in downtown Muskegon has been closed since April 2015 due to the need for extensive repairs.
Diocese of Grand Rapids spokeswoman Annalise Laumeyer said no repairs have been completed since the building’s closure.
Authorities in Kalamazoo and Indiana were searching for her, and, so far, the case was being treated as a missing person.